Music Business: Labels, Royalties and AI Rules — 2026-09-26
The week's defining story is the split between licensing and litigation: Suno launched its licensed v6 model with Warner, BMG and Believe, while Sony and Universal responded days later with a fresh infringement suit alleging the new model still copies 60,000+ protected works. Meanwhile IFPI launched a joint industry initiative against streaming fraud, and a CDU-style copyright ruling in Munich continues to reverberate: songwriters now look to the Phono V rate proceedings to reshape mechanical royalties.
Music Business: Labels, Royalties and AI Rules — 2026-09-26
Top developments
Sony and Universal file new lawsuit against Suno over licensed v6 model
DAYS after Suno introduced v6 — the company's first licensed music model family, trained with Warner, BMG and Believe — Sony and Universal filed a new lawsuit alleging that the model's code still incorporates content from more than 60,000 copyrighted works. The suit comes even as Universal simultaneously licenses its catalog to Udio and Spotify, making at least one major label both partner and plaintiff. The outcome could force every AI music company to license training data or exit the market.
Labels licensed catalogs to AI firms they once sued — and payouts are opaque
The Los Angeles Times (Sept 21) reports that labels which sued AI music makers are now licensing to them, but payout terms are undisclosed and lawsuits continue, leaving musicians asking who actually benefits. Sony remains the holdout: it filed a second lawsuit against Udio covering more than 30,000 recordings and is still suing Suno alongside Universal. For Universal and Warner, licensing revenue could become a new income stream — but artist distribution of those sums is unresolved.
IFPI and BVMI launch joint initiative against streaming fraud
On September 14, IFPI — international umbrella body of Germany's labels association BVMI — launched an industry-wide initiative against streaming fraud (i.e., manipulated streams that divert royalty pools). German trade radioszene covered it on ~Sept 20. Fraudulent streams dilute the royalty pool for everyone, so platforms and majors have a direct financial interest in detection — Spotify already leans on tools like Believe's AI Radar to flag undisclosed AI content.
Phono V royalty proceedings could reshape songwriter mechanicals
Writing in Billboard this week, Alex Heiche (Sound Royalties) argues songwriters should watch the Phono V royalty rate proceedings, which will set mechanical rates with long-term effects on catalogs' cash flow and thus catalogue valuations. With catalog deal values now a formal asset class — roughly $20 billion a year flowing into catalogs, per one industry map this week — even small rate changes ripple through acquisition multiples.
AI rules stay detection- and labeling-based, not blanket bans
Streaming services are not banning AI tracks outright: Spotify and Apple Music use detection tools — including Believe's AI Radar — to flag undisclosed AI content while admitting licensed, labeled material, and Spotify will tag "AI personas" and exclude AI tracks from personalized recommendations. The US Copyright Office's position remains unchanged: purely prompt-generated tracks cannot be copyrighted. For majors this means policing uploads (as in UMG's suit against DistroKid for "AI slop") rather than fighting the technology itself.
Local view
German-language outlets frame the Suno fight through GEMA's Munich win (July), with delamar reporting the fresh Sony/Universal suit and emphasizing the 60,000+ works allegedly embedded in Suno's code. Radioszene highlights the industry uniting against Streaming-Betrug (streaming fraud) under the IFPI initiative joined by the German labels association BVMI.
Context & numbers
- Global recorded music revenue grew 6.4% to surpass $30 billion for the first time; streaming passed $22 billion (69.6% of the total) and paid subscription accounts hit 837 million at end-2025.
- Vinyl rose 13.7%, its 19th consecutive growth year.
- Spotify ended Q1 2026 with 761M MAUs, 293M Premium subscribers and €4.5 billion quarterly revenue at a 33% gross margin.
- H1 2026 catalog deal activity totaled ~$3.5 billion, with ~220x-West mapping roughly $20 billion/year flowing into catalog assets.
On the radar
- Phono V rate proceedings: milestone dates and interventions will determine songwriter mechanical rates; watch for CRB filings.
- Sony's second Udio lawsuit (30,000+ recordings) and the new Suno complaint: watch for answers/counter-fair-use arguments from the AI side.
- Whether undisclosed Suno-Warner/BMG/Believe licensing economics will ever be disclosed — rumor per LA Times reporting is that artist payout splits remain an open sore; treat shareholder artist-benefit claims cautiously.
- Private equity's move into indie labels (Rolling Stone, late Sept): rumored further indie-label acquisitions could squeeze independent distributors.
This content was collected, curated, and summarized entirely by AI — including how and what to gather. It may contain inaccuracies. Crew does not guarantee the accuracy of any information presented here. Always verify facts on your own before acting on them. Crew assumes no legal liability for any consequences arising from reliance on this content.
Powered by
